Search 2,255,314 property listings in 25,909 cities
updated 51 minutes ago.



Bay Shore, NY Homes for Sale; Bay Shore Real Estate

Comprehensive real estate search in the Bay Shore area. We have over 591 listings to browse so you can find your perfect home. Whether you are looking through our 584 MLS properties, 7 for sale by owner, — you're sure to find your next property with Roost.com.


  • 263 Helm Ln Bay Shore,NY 11706-8109
    $595,000
    3 Bd | 3 Ba
    263 Helm Ln Bay Shore, NY 11706-8109
    Single Family Home | For Sale By Owner
  • 8 Cooper Ln Bay Shore,NY 11706-7806
    $541,000
    3 Bd | 2 Ba
    8 Cooper Ln Bay Shore, NY 11706-7806
    Single Family Home | For Sale By Owner

View our 7 For Sale By Owner Listings in Bay Shore

We've gathered For Sale By Owner listings for you. Filter them by price, bed bath, neighborhood, school district and more. Here are just a few of our FSBO listings...

View more For Sale By Owner ListingsSearch Real Estate Listings
About Bay Shore, New York

The reality is that you're not looking for a house. You're looking for a home, and more-a space where you and your loved ones can feel secure, stimulated, and comfortable. Our Bay Shore homes for sale and real estate listings are the most comprehensive available. You can search Roost.com for all your real estate needs; including Multiple Listing Service ( MLS ) properties for sale; homes for sale by owner (FSBO); new construction listings and foreclosures / foreclosed properties.

There are 538 residential MLS listings available with an average price of $336,410. Popular neighborhoods include: Bay Shore, North Bay Shore and Baywood. You may be interested in homes for sale in these school districts: Bay Shore Union Free, Brentwood Union Free and Islip Union Free. Streets with the most MLS listings include: Manatuck Blvd, N Thompson Dr and Thompson Dr.

Are you looking for tangible features or are you looking for a home in the Bay Shore real estate market that just feels right? Start with the basics like number of beds and baths then use our intuitive filters to zero in on homes for sale by neighborhood or school district. You can even search for amenities such as pool, remodeled kitchen, hardwood and more! Roost is the perfect search for your perfect home.

Residential Property Listing Facts
  Avg Price Price/Sq Ft 0-250k 251-500k 501-750k 751-1M 1M+
MLS Listings $336,410 $185 233 258 29 8 10
For Sale By Owner $421,700 $230 1 3 3 0 0
The Foreclosures in these 10 markets would fill 4,000 football fields

What does it say about a real estate market when there are more square feet tied up in various states of forclosure than there are currently available for sale? Read More

These MLS listings represent the most currently available real estate including single family homes, multiple family homes, condos, foreclosures and other property types for CITY NAME STATE. These residences are featured by BROKER NAME via Broker Reciprocity with the data updated nightly. Too many listings? Then refine your search by price, bedrooms, baths, square feet (lot size), or even local school district. Then work with our REALTOR(R) partners to find the perfect home for sale, and help you find the right mortgage financing, best mortgage rates & right insurance policies for your needs.
Have you considered buying a home in one of these nearby locations?
Click to expand map view of listings
Featured Homes
  • 1073 Manor Ln Bay Shore,NY 11706-6224
    1073 Manor Ln
    3 Bd | 2 Ba
    Single Family Home | For Sale By Owner
  • 136 Mariner Ln Bay Shore,NY 11706-8119
    136 Mariner Ln
    3 Bd | 3 Ba
    Condo | For Sale By Owner
  • 213 Pine Dr Bay Shore,NY 11706-7117
    213 Pine Dr
    3 Bd | 1 Ba
    Single Family Home | For Sale By Owner
  • 406 Brook Ave Bay Shore,NY 11706-5643
    406 Brook Ave
    3 Bd | 2 Ba
    Single Family Home | For Sale By Owner
  • 1467 Lincoln Blvd Bay Shore,NY 11706-3904
    1467 Lincoln Blvd
    4 Bd | 2 Ba
    Single Family Home | For Sale By Owner
Real Estate Brokers in the area
  • Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC
  • Century 21 American Homes
  • Winkler Real Estate Inc
  • Prudential Douglas Elliman RE
  • Arvy Realty
  • Millennium Homes
  • Power Team Realty Corp
  • RE/MAX Signature Real Estate
Why People Prefer Roost

Most real estate sites rely on individuals to upload their own listings. This usually results in a fragmented and partial view of what homes are truly available for sale. Even worse, it often means stale info. We partner with the local "Multiple Listing Services" ( MLS ) and local real estate brokers in Bay Shore to ensure you have access to not only the most complete, but also the most up-to-date homes for sale available.


Give Feedback